Shaggy shepherd dog resting in a dry field at dusk, looking at the camera

When Two Vets Disagree: How to Decide What's Right for Your Dog

November 10, 2026•3 min read

What should I do when two vets disagree about my dog's treatment?

Start by working out which question each vet is answering: what can be done medically, or what should be done for this dog, in this home, with this family. Two vets who disagree are often both giving good advice. Ask each one what they expect with and without treatment, and the gap usually turns out smaller than it felt in the exam room.

By Dr. Judith Samson-French, DVM, MSc. Last reviewed: November 2026

Vet #1: "Let's operate."

Vet #2: "Let's wait."

You: "Can I lie down on the clinic floor?"

(Same, honestly.)

Getting two different recommendations is one of the most stressful moments for a dog guardian. You trust both vets. You want to do the right thing. And now you feel like you have to choose who is right.

They may be answering different questions

After more than 30 years in practice, I've seen that two vets who disagree are often both giving good advice. They may simply be answering different questions:

  • "What can we do?" This is the medical question: what treatments exist and what they might achieve.
  • "What should we do for this dog, in this home, with this family?" This is the decision question. It weighs the dog's age, temperament, how he copes with handling and recovery, your finances, your schedule, and what a good life means for him.

A surgeon focused on the first question may say operate. A vet who knows your dog's history may be weighing the second and say wait.

Your job isn't to pick a winner

It's to work out which question you're trying to answer. The medical option and the best decision for your dog aren't always the same thing.

Questions to ask both vets

  • What do you expect to happen if we do this, and if we don't?
  • What will recovery look like for him, day to day?
  • How likely is success, and what does "success" mean here?
  • What would you do if he were your dog?
  • What would make you change your recommendation?

Write down the answers. Often, once both opinions are side by side, the disagreement turns out to be smaller than it felt in the exam room.

When you need help thinking it through

If you're still stuck between two paths, a Decision Consult gives you time to talk through your own dog's situation with me: not to replace your vets, but to help you sort out which question matters most to you.

Related: The Decision

Educational content only. Not a substitute for veterinary advice.

Dr. Judith Samson-French

Dr. Judith Samson-French

Dr. Judith is a veterinarian with more than 30 years of experience, including work in Indigenous communities across Alberta. She founded HUMM to help dog guardians notice what is changing and make hard decisions with confidence.

LinkedIn logo icon
Back to Blog
Love, Baxter Approved

© 2026 HUMM · Dr. Judith Samson-French

These roadmaps are for educational purposes only and do not constitute veterinary medical advice.